Collection: Salt Water Taffy

Discover our Pick n Mix Salt Water Taffy collection—a vibrant assortment of chewy, handcrafted taffy in all your favorite flavors. Handpicked from coastal candy makers, each piece bursts with nostalgic taste and bright colors. Mix and match as many flavors as you like to create your perfect 1- or 2-pound blend: from classic vanilla and rainbow sherbet to tangy sour apple and berry swirl. Whether you’re stocking up for movie nights, gifting a sweet surprise, or simply treating yourself, our Salt Water Taffy collection promises a fun, flavorful experience in every bite.